Blackout – failure of critical infrastructure
A blackout is usually an unintentional interruption in the supply of electricity.
Differentiation from a power outage
Power outages are always short-term and usually only affect smaller areas. The causes are often quickly remedied. In contrast, with a “real” blackout, the power supply is interrupted for a longer period of time; larger areas are usually affected, such as several federal states or nations. The causes can also be intentional interruptions.
In the event of a blackout, the critical infrastructure always suffers, starting with the network infrastructure.
Causes
The causes of a blackout can be of various kinds. A selection:
- Natural causes
- Failure of weather-dependent renewable energies (wind and solar power);
- natural disasters;
- Solar Storms/Geomagnetic Storms;
- Technical causes
- Grid stabilizers (coal, nuclear energy) are increasingly being eliminated;
- System collapse – Insufficient network stability;
- Human causes
- Human error
- cyber attacks;
- Terrorist attacks;
- e-bomb;
- Market manipulation.
Deutsche Welle: Total power outage – realistic scenario or scaremongering?
Prof. Harald Schwarz on the last serious incident in Europe in January 2021. He clearly explains why the power supply in Germany will not necessarily be secure at all times in the future.
How to cause a blackout
An analysis by Mathias Dalheimer at the Chaos Computer Club Congress 32C3
Effect (selection)
The consequences of a blackout affect all areas of our economy and life. The entire infrastructure depends on a functioning power supply.
To name just a few examples of consequences:
- Many freezers and refrigerators (especially those with insufficient thermal insulation) become too warm, causing the stored goods to spoil.
- Many transport systems (especially electric trains, but also lifts) are failing, meaning that important transport services are no longer available. Employees and goods no longer come to the production or service locations.
- Obtaining goods and services is no longer possible because electronic payment systems are no longer available
- The failure of lighting in apartments, offices and industrial companies can severely disrupt processes there.
- The transmission of information through telephones, television and radio, email and newspapers can be interrupted, with dire consequences, especially for an industrial society.
- Hospitals and other critical facilities must have backup power. However, this usually cannot bridge power outages of any length because the batteries or fuel reserves are exhausted.
- Water supplies may also be affected, with further serious consequences.
- For example, farms can no longer operate their milking machines, water and wastewater systems can no longer function, and warehouses can no longer be cooled.
- If there is a shortage of information and supplies that lasts several days, social unrest occurs;
- A black start is extremely time-consuming. It takes days or weeks until the energy supply is stable again;
- etc.
There are numerous studies on the effects of a blackout, including the Office for Technology Assessment at the German Bundestag with the publication “What happens in a blackout: Consequences of a long-lasting and large-scale power outage” in 2011. See also Sources.
The publication of the German Bundestag:
Probability of a blackout occurring
Blackouts have an increasing probability of occurrence while at the same time having a high negative impact. The probability of occurrence in terms of frequency or extent depends, among other things, on the following factors:
- Increases with complexity of the power grid;
- Increases with possible chain reactions (domino effect);
- Increasing electrification in all areas of business and life increases vulnerability;
- Increasing electricity production that cannot be planned in the long term increases risk.
Solutions
In order to avoid a blackout or mitigate its consequences, there are various solutions (selection):
- General network expansion, creation of electricity-transporting network infrastructure;
- Networking of the electricity infrastructure between producers and consumers;
- feed-in management measures;
- Contractual or automatic load shedding for large customers;
- Black start capable systems;
- Creation of electricity storage (batteries);
- Fast-reacting pumped storage and natural gas power plants.
Private precautionary measures
In addition, every private individual can take precautionary measures for disasters; the Federal Office for Civil Protection and Disaster Assistance (BBK) has created a checklist for this purpose.
Precautionary measures for companies, authorities and organizations
Structures such as authorities, organizations and companies are called upon to prepare for a blackout with emergency concepts to protect themselves and their employees. For this purpose, it is advisable to set up a task force to identify the necessary resources and measures.
TCRH Offers
The TCRH Mosbach offers Education and training in the fields of Civil protection, Disaster preparedness, Inner and External security.
The following courses are available for crisis scenarios such as a blackout or its consequences:
We are happy to offer our conference rooms, accommodation and catering options as well as face-to-face and digital platforms for exchange as well as education and training to congresses, meetings, workshops and expert forums.
Sources
- Offices for Technology Assessment at the German Bundestag: “What happens in a blackout: Consequences of a long-lasting and large-scale power outage”, https://www.deutsche-digitale-bibliothek.de/item/WHTYG6UICVSOLBM53WFUM3RFBFYCW5HM
- Federal Office for Civil Protection and Disaster Assistance (BBK): “Blackout – What to do if the power goes out”, https://www.bbk.bund.de/DE/TopThema/TT_2018/TT_Blackout.html
- Federal Office for Civil Protection and Disaster Assistance (BBK): “Guide for emergency preparedness and correct action in emergency situations”, https://www.bbk.bund.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/BBK/DE/Publikationen/Broschueren_Flyer/Buergerinformationen_A4/Ratgeber_Brosch.html;jsessionid=1C1A15FC7882E1C009743E3366E794CF.1_cid508
- Civil Defense Austria: “Blackout – the long-term power outage”, http://zivilschutzverband.at/de/aktuelles/84/Blackout-der-laengerfristige-Stromausfall
- acatech – German Academy of Engineering Sciences e.V.: “Fit for the future: Science academies present options for resilient, digitalized energy systems,” https://energiesysteme-zukunft.de/presse/meldung/resilienz-digitalisierter-energiesysteme
- VDE Association of Electrical Engineering Electronics Information Technology e.V., Ralf Butscher: “Risk Blackout”, https://www.vde.com/topics-de/energy/aktuelles/risiko-blackout
- Saurugg, Herbert: “A Europe-wide power, infrastructure and supply failure (“blackout”)”, https://www.saurugg.net/blackout
- Energy Lexicon, Dr. Rüdiger Paschotta: “Power failure”, https://www.energie-lexikon.info/stromausfall.html
- stromauss.info, Thomas Reicher: “How can a blackout happen? Can it be prevented?" https://www.stromausfall.info/wie-kann-ein-blackout-passieren-kann-man-ihn-verhindern_de_n2760.html
- Addendum: “Country without electricity – Possible causes of a blackout”, https://www.addendum.org/blackout/ursachen/
- addendum.de: “Nothing works anymore – the effects of a blackout”, https://www.addendum.org/blackout/auswirkungen/
- Federal Ministry of Education and Research: “Inter-municipal concepts to strengthen the resilience of metropolitan areas (INTERKOM)”, https://www.sifo.de/de/interkom-interkommunale-konzepte-zur-staerkung-der-resilienz-von-ballungsgebieten-2167.html and in particular “Intermunicipal concepts involving the population to strengthen the resilience of metropolitan areas: Interkom: sub-project Intermunicipal concepts involving the population to strengthen the resilience of metropolitan areas to a large-scale, long-term power outage: Final report”, https://www.tib.eu/de/suchen/id/TIBKAT%3A898811899/Interkommunale-Konzepte-unter-Einbeziehung-der/?tx_tibsearch_search%5Bsearchspace%5D=tibub
- Federal Nuclear Safety Inspectorate ENSI: “Nuclear power plants are armed against solar storms,” https://www.ensi.ch/de/2011/12/13/kernkraftwerke-sind-gegen-sonnensturme-gewappnet/
- Federal Office for Civil Protection BABS: “Sunstorm”, National Risk Analysis “Disasters and Emergencies Switzerland”, https://www.babs.admin.ch/content/babs-internet/de/aufgabenbabs/gefaehrdrisiken/natgefaehrdanalyse/gefaehrddossier/_jcr_content/contentPar/accordion/accordionItems/naturbedingte_gef_hr/accordionPar/downloadlist/downloadItems/142_1604482773548.download/15-Sonnensturm-GD-de.pdf
- The Weather Channel, Odenwald, Michael: “Fatal consequences: How a strong solar storm could destroy our everyday lives in 90 seconds,” https://weather.com/de-DE/wissen/astronomie/news/2018-05-07-fatale-folgen-wie-ein-starker-sonnensturm-in-90-sekunden-unseren
- correctiv, Kutzner Stefan: “Blackout: How the scenario of a long, widespread power outage is exploited for scaremongering and profit,” Blackout: How the catastrophe scenario is exploited for scaremongering (correctiv.org)
- KfV, Georgiev Stefan: “Technological disasters: The “blackout” phenomenon, Technology Disasters_EF-1.pdf (kfv.at)
- Federal Office for Civil Protection and Disaster Relief: Guide & Checklist – BBK (bund.de)
- Energy Security Association: Blackout, Blackout 2022 – The possible power outage in Germany (verein-energiesicherheit.de)
- 24hamburg: Preparing for the blackout: The checklist for the power outage (24hamburg.de)
- Northern Bavaria: Federal Office publishes list: You need these things in the event of a blackout – Panorama | Northern Bavaria
Publications
- BWK Energie: “Electricity: Europe narrowly misses the blackout,” https://www.ingenieur.de/fachmedien/bwk/energieversorgung/strom-europa-schrammt-am-blackout-knapp-vorbei/
- Spektrum, Nestler, Ralf: “Power supply: What should protect against the big blackout”, https://www.spektrum.de/news/stromversorgung-wie-verhindert-man-europaweite-blackouts/1828780
- Handelsblatt, Witsch, Kathrin: “Handelsblatt Energy Summit: Shortly before blackout: Europe’s power grid almost collapsed in January,” https://www.handelsblatt.com/unternehmen/energie/handelsblatt-energie-gipfel-kurz-vor-blackout-europas-stromnetz-waere-im-januar-fast-zusammengebrochen/26820168.html?ticket=ST-4953358-7dftXdhfDP2b4O3u7jT9-ap4
- agrarheute, Zinke, Dr. Olaf: “Blackout in Agriculture – The Catastrophe. Power failure and the consequences ", https://www.agrarheute.com/management/betriebsfuehrung/blackout-landwirtschaft-katastrophe-577604
- kommunal.de: “When the power grids collapse: research project on the blackout”, https://kommunal.de/stromausfall-pandemie
- Neue Zürcher Zeitung, Titz, Sven: “The next devastating solar storm is sure to come,” https://www.nzz.ch/wissenschaft/der-naechste-verheerende-sonnensturm-kommt-bestimmt-ld.1335543
- faz.net, “A look at solar activity over the next eleven years,” https://www.faz.net/aktuell/wissen/weltraum/ein-blick-auf-die-sonnenaktivitaet-der-naechsten-elf-jahre-17003444.html
- brand eins, Dilba, Denis: “Tornado in the Galaxy”, https://www.brandeins.de/magazine/brand-eins-wirtschaftsmagazin/2018/wetter/tornado-in-der-galaxie
- telepolis, Rötzer, Florian: “About blackout and EMP bombs, hacks and paragliders”, https://www.heise.de/tp/features/Von-Blackout-und-EMP-Bomben-Hacks-und-Paraglidern-3858578.html?seite=all
- spiegelonline: Gongolsky, Mario: “E-Bomb: The Electric Nightmare”, https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/tech/e-bombe-der-elektrische-alptraum-a-242078.html
- National Geographic, Lovett Richard A: “What would happen if the biggest solar storm of all time started today?”, https://www.nationalgeographic.de/wissenschaft/was-wuerde-passieren-wenn-heute-der-groesste-sonnensturm-aller-zeiten-losbraeche
- National Geographic: Röck Markus, Blackout: What happens when nothing works anymore? | National Geographic
- ZDFheut: Risks for power supply – Will electricity also be scarce in winter? Risks for supply: Will electricity also be scarce in winter? – ZDFheute
Leave a Comment